People will go to great lengths attempting to avoid discomfort. And as traders, much of what we do is in response to being uncomfortable. This is an extremely critical concept to understand and explains many trading problems and mistakes. The problem is not in being uncomfortable per se, the real problem is that our efforts to avoid discomfort can easily end up making us feel worse. If you can understand why you’re uncomfortable and what your typical default reaction is to being uncomfortable, you will be well on the road to trading success.
Here are a few sign posts along the road to get you started: You avoid the discomfort of boredom by taking marginal trades. You try to avoid the discomfort associated with the fear of missing out by chasing. You deal with the anger of getting stopped by taking a revenge trade. You try to avoid the discomfort of being wrong by hesitating or freezing, or holding the position past your stop to prove you were ‘right’.
See the pattern? Most trading mistakes can be viewed as behavior in response to some type of discomfort.
Mistakes must be seen as learning opportunities. And that’s not just a cliché. If you don’t learn from your mistakes, 1) they become emotional baggage that weighs you down, and 2) you will be destined to repeat them.
For this reason alone, it behooves you to learn about the patterns of your discomfort. Yes, discomfort often does come in patterns, but we are so focused outward on the chart that many people do not recognize the emotional sequence going on inside. You can’t eliminate your emotions but you can learn to control (or ‘re-condition’) your response (your reaction) to the discomfort by being aware of and understanding your emotions. Part of what I do with my coaching clients is teach them to be aware of their internal patterns and how these internal patterns correspond to what they see on their charts and in their actions.
I write my blog articles with the intention of helping as many traders as possible. I enjoy reading emails from people who benefit from my writing. And in that spirit (to help you and therefore give myself some enjoyment) I’m going to give you some important advice. At first glance this may seem ridiculous to you, but I know it is true based on my own personal trading experience and working with very large bank traders, hedge fund traders, and independent traders; many of them didn’t believe it at first but they do now. Here it is: Being motivated by money is necessary but often not enough by itself to make us better traders; motivation to understand oneself is often the missing piece. I’m not talking about contemplating your navel as a trading strategy; I am saying that expanded awareness leads to choice, which leads to personal efficacy. (The U.S. Defense Dept. hired me as a consultant many years ago to teach this to select groups and individuals.)
Here’s an example that you might be able to relate to. Most traders have set-ups or entry signals that are supposedly based on a probability of something happening; therefore most traders will say that you need to think in terms of probabilities. However, most people don’t really think in terms of probabilities, they think in ‘degrees of certainty’. To actually think in probabilities requires that you accept uncertainty; the word ‘should’ is not part of the definition of probability. The discomfort that naturally comes with uncertainty can become too much for a trader who may be lacking in self-understanding and therefore they either inject a ‘should’ into the probability and/or they end up hesitating or freezing at the moment when action is required. The ability to truly think and operate in probabilities requires that you become aware of your discomfort and your pattern of maladaptive response to it.
There are lots tools available to help you improve your trading including emotion analytics, various self-management systems, bio-feedback, mental rehearsal and visualization, Neuro Linguistic Programming (NLP), mindfulness, and others. In my coaching work I draw from a wide variety of tools to best match the unique personality and needs of the trader.
Andrew, I enjoyed your article especially where you explain how the word ‘should’ (in a trader’s mind) is a warning to themselves that they have not ‘truly’ accepted the notion of thinking in probabilities. A warning of something that needs to be fixed.
Rob,
Yes, that’s a good way to look at it, part of an early warning system. As a corollary I would add that the degree of frustration one feels is directly proportional to the degree that one demands the market conform to their demands or expectations.
Increased awareness of our thoughts and feelings is one of the most under-utilized but most potentially rewarding endeavors for a trader.
Andrew Menaker
Hi Andrew. Thanks for the post. Your post talks at a different level when experience is fresh in mind.
Today I missed multiple trades by a tick and in last few minutes of the session made two trades – one marginal trade and 2nd was breaking my rule on 2nd attempts. In retrospect, these two trades are good examples of boredom, missing out and revenge trade.
Interestingly, when I read your prior post on disppointment few days back the insights I had were more about its impact post session. Today I understand another aspect of that post i.e., disappointment impact within the session.
Bright side, now that I am aware of few things I used to do/not do post session in past (when I had disappointing session), today I will be working to not fall in that trap 🙂
Excellent.
keep up the good work.
Andrew Menaker
[…] ways to improve your performance, it would serve you well to engage in efforts that make you more resilient in the face of disappointment. Watch my free webinar on Self-Confidence for some ideas and tips. In that webinar I define […]
Hi Andrew,
I just found your blog and want to say that after reading through a lot of your posts, I think you are an excellent resource for traders. I’ve been trading for about 7 years now and have been quite profitable since late 2007 (in equities and now in futures), and a lot of the things I’ve learned over the past few years as I’ve developed as a trader really found voice in many of your posts. The idea that trade management is far more important than finding the “right setup”, and the idea that thinking in terms of how much you are willing to risk to find out if you hypothesis about the market is correct really resonated with me and are defining characteristics of how I think about the market.
I also think your posts on the idea that we don’t perceive an objective market, but rather it’s filtered by our beliefs/emotions/expectations is right on target and that knowing those things about ourselves allows us to control or at least mitigate the negative effects those things can have on our trading.
While it seems like your blog is mainly geared towards helping struggling traders figure out their “demons” and get to the next level, it still has the capability to cause me to have internal dialogues about my trading that have generated a few interesting insights. Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts. I’ve bookmarked your blog and look forward with interest to future posts.
Jesse
P.S. One interesting set of posts you could write would be about perceiving the dominant emotions in the market at a given time and using those to our advantage… Sort of like feeling the rookie trader within all of us and initiating the trade that would take his money.
Jesse,
Thanks for the positive feedback.
I’ve written a bit about looking for emotions in the market, or reading the
behavior of others and inferring what they may be thinking doing
https://andrewmenaker.com/trading-the-web-of-relationships/ I also talk
about this more with my clients. And I may incorporate more of this in my
next free public webinar in July.
Andrew